This topic also contains some areas where YOU.. the BoD have failed, but related to website issue in general
I'll start out by making some comments and observations then ... let the BoD take this where they want to as far as the total discussion. I play a role here of putting forth the questions and some of the answers to get the brain juices flowing, then as I said.. let the BoD and members take this topic wherever they want to ... No agenda here .. just address 'where to host'. I think you will find there is a lot .. a lot to discuss on the mechanics of same.
From this point on things that *I* , Tbar, says .. are not my words in the sense that I'm just putting out things to be considered. *I*, as Tbar am not dictating, just presenting. Truth, Fact .. and how it will be is up to the BoD.. always has been.
You = BoD.. past and present members including the Director and some "managers"We = BoD ..All of us as BoD members.. past and present including some 'managers'
When the BoD and this current site were set up .. we used all we could that would be NO COST so that the USAAC could be off and running without the need for 'money' and all the complications that it brings. The objective was not where to get money .. but get the USAAC started and working. Money is evil, money is power .. all the things we needed to avoid at the onset .. but should not be totally ignored at this point either..
First off "costs' is not a big deal .. the BoD has deep pockets and can get funds. But Funding in itself is a serious topic the BoD thus far has never had to address. You want "independence" than think it all thru carefully. Agreements and Handshakes can be funny things and are not something you can take lightly. Money, donation, accountability .. take time and a lot of work.
1) How will you collect funds and who pays the bill?
You will now have to have a 'treasurer' .. and that person cannot have a 'vote' on the BoD, it can't be anyone that is an elected voice. Why? Its called stacking the deck and "power". Oh, but we trust that person. So be it .. but you don't have 'independence' then do you? This topic of collecting money and 'treasurer' could be a topic unto itself.
You can find a totally 'free' site. Ok.. but then once again.. your not in total control nor do you have true 'independence'.
OK.. now at a risk.. let me pull some comments from other threads and just post them here .. make some replies and then let the show begin (nice show I hope).
First Off so there is no offense to anyone:
You = just people , not any one individual
We = USAAC BoD
Ok, once again ..do you have control and are your truly independent? Maybe.. You have or will have a new Web Master soon .. trust his input or toss him outI have a friend .. who is a DP manager .. and he said ..
In the 'other thread Pop said":
What is the difference? What make these USAAC independent by that move?Firestorm can host it no charge on a server he has.
Good Question.Do any of you know what you are talking about?
When you pick another "host" you do this so you can be "totally independent".. So address the REAL question .. independent of "what"?
Here are some soul searching questions/answers. You may not agree .. but give it some thought.
FACT:
There is NO AA Community Site that is "Totally Independent" .. none... in the sense that you project the 'need'. Do some fact finding yourself.
FACT:
USAAC is totally independent.. they can do what ever they want... more so than GE or UK/ And always could. Do some research yourself.. you will find many answers rigth there in the USAAC forums!
You make out like you don't have control .. like you don't have a say so .. like you have to accept any dictate that is pushed in your face. Yet you can't think of .. or place as an example, nothing like that .. not one example.
You make statement and innuendo .. but never put forth one single thing that has caused you a problem that YOU were not in control of. You have this propensity to 'blame' others rather than the real source of the problem which is YOU.
You whine that you need independence.. like you can't do what you really need too. Name one thing.. just one.
You make like your part of a huge conspiracy that has an evil money making agenda. Well Mr Intelligent .. name one.
You make statements similar to: Well we should move the site because some people don't feel comfortable.
Are you then going to move the site every month because "some don't feel comfortable"?
Will you move the site each month to change the color?
Will you move the site each month because there is a new member on the BoD who can get us a 'better deal'.
Will you move the site every month because you trust Mr x more than Mr y?
Get real.. get a grip on things gents. Talk to people who know their business.
You make out like there is a great 'evil' and secret dirty deals going on. Point them out so they can be corrected.
FACT
The BoD has never once .. ever .. asked Townet folks to do anything .. that TowNet did not do for them.
FACT
Political Ads. No one ever noticed or pointed out they were "political". Tbar takes responsibility for that error in that he was simply looking for something funny to display that did not take day to day maintenance .. its syndicated ..and dynamically displayed. It was intended to fill a gap in the front page. Sorry, Tbar never saw it as political because he never really read them. As far as the 'black guy and white girl thing.. never really noticed as its a cartoon.
The BoD never asked for that cartoon to be taken down .. never. The BoD never asked the USAAC webmaster to take it down or change it .. not once. If they had .. no big deal. Now its some kind of "major issue" like its being 'jammed' down someone throat and forced upon them. This is a BOD failure .. no one else's. If its a problem.. address it.. issue orders to the Web Master to 'remove and replace'. While your at it .. you might suggest a replacement and save the Web Master some valuable time.
FACT
The BOD approved the Google Ads.
The BoD never asked for them to be removed at any time either.
The Google Ads are 'content' generated. It is not the fault of the BoD or ToW if Google fracks up now and then. No one I know is smarter than the folks at Google .. errors are just made from time to time.
Quote from another area
I would answer this post as follows: The site is not identical in any way .. but do you like the layout. Moving the site has nothing to do with improving the site look, feel and functionality. The point is a better working site and trying to improve and react to complaints about the site. This work is being done .. because the BoD wanted it done.Will the new site be moved to it's own server and will the forums be moved also?
If not then whats the point ??
The new site looks almost identical to this one.
Quote from another area
When the BoD decides .. we will let you know. What you see now is simply asking if you like the layout.. and should we continue the efforts.I would assume it would have it's own cyberspace, correct me if I'm wrong.
Quote from another area
Here is that word "independence again .. I'm now thinking its a planned agenda ::Shrugs::: .. and what the heck to 'squads' have to do with this all? Is their one squad that is "independent" of the people who control their website? I think not .. and certainly no differently that the USAAC and in some case the squad members have NO SAY SO AT ALLUSAAC's independence should be discussed which our host TOW should be complimented as well for there work.
The overhead to go on it's own is not that costly afterall there are Squads that have there own setups.
Quote From another area
This site belongs to the BoD. The BoD belongs to the member squads, the Director of the USAAC belongs to the member people who are NOT squad members. The BoD and Director "owns this site".... Remember kids this site does not belong to any one person ,nor does it belong to the BOD. It is the US clubsite and should listen to all involved in it...
-----------------------------end